An influential group of MPs said giving the taxman the power to recover money directly from personal bank accounts without some form of prior independent oversight would be "wholly unacceptable".
The Commons Treasury Committee also dismissed George Osborne's argument that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) already had similar powers to collect child maintenance.
The parallel is not exact: in those cases, DWP is acting as an intermediary between two individuals.
HMRC [HM Revenue and Customs] would be acting not as an intermediary between two individuals but rather in pursuit of its own objective of bringing in revenue for the Exchequer.
More top news
Tuesday: After a bright start, rain will gradually push northeastwards across England and Wales with strong winds developing.
Britain should have a second vote on the terms of exiting the EU if it can secure a new deal to control its borders, Jeremy Hunt has said.
Complaints have been lodged with the chairman of the 1922 committee over the neutrality of government whips.