Scotland needs almost 500,000 migrants over the next 20 years to achieve the same age balance as the UK, according to the Treasury.
It means an independent Scotland would have to treble its rate of net annual migration to reach the same ratio of pensioners to working-age adults as Britain.
The ageing population is one of five key areas considered in the Treasury's latest analysis assessing the implications of an independent Scotland.
The Treasury said that currently "all of this challenge is simply smoothed away within the union and borne across the population as a whole."
More top news
Low pressure brings cooler, showery conditions over the next week
100-year-old tourist mugged by stranger after he fell getting off a bus as he returned to Gloucester where he used to live.
The case of a child killer who was the first person to be convicted under DNA evidence is to be reviewed by the Parole Board.