Mike Down, of accountancy firm Baker Tilly, said the HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) should be checking tax returns to see whether individuals had already explained their circumstances.
He told the Daily Telegraph that The Revenue is "adopting a computer says yes approach, rather than simply checking the tax returns".
One case involved an elderly widow whose effective tax rate was low because she was giving more than half her income to charity.
More top news
After flooding and thunderstorms, a quieter night ahead
Boris Johnson announces funds for troubled country in a bid to stop an influx of illegal migrants and terrorists taking advantage of chaos.
The former US Presidential candidate says her "skin crawled" during her infamous second TV debate with Donald Trump in a new memoir.