Mike Down, of accountancy firm Baker Tilly, said the HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) should be checking tax returns to see whether individuals had already explained their circumstances.
He told the Daily Telegraph that The Revenue is "adopting a computer says yes approach, rather than simply checking the tax returns".
One case involved an elderly widow whose effective tax rate was low because she was giving more than half her income to charity.
More top news
David Cameron sets out his case for British jets and drones to strike so-called Islamic State targets in Syria in an address to the Commons.
A drink-driver who "destroyed the lives" of two mothers was allowed to have his curfew lifted so he could go on a foreign stag party.
Demonstrators have blockaded the entrance tunnel to Heathrow Airport in apparent protest at plans to build a third runway.