Naming and shaming doctors for missing cancer symptoms is "not going to make any real difference," one GP told ITV News.
Dr. Chaan Nagpul said: "We mustn't get into the situation where we are blaming doctors for presentations that are difficult to diagnose."
He added: "If cancer was a simple condition to diagnose at an early stage it wouldn't be a killer disease. It's a killer disease because it does actually deceive the patient and deceive the doctor."
Were doctors names and would be worried that the system would quickly become clogged up as doctors began referring everyone who had the faintest possibility of cancer to hospital, he said.
He added: "It may reduce access for those patients to specialists to those patients who do have cancer."
More top news
This defeat for Theresa May matters: it shows the fury among some MPs, notably those who voted to Remain, that they are being ignored.
Theresa May's government has been narrowly defeated in a key Commons vote after a rebellion by Conservative MPs.
Despite temperatures reaching double figures in the south today, it was still a chilly day, with brisk winds.