Scottish Independence Convention chair Elaine C Smith and Labour MSP Kezia Dugdale are clashing passionately about whether social injustice could best be tackled under an independent Scotland.
"We're supposed to vote Labour, get to the back of the bus and shut up," Smith says, arguing that Scots would benefit from having the centre of power closer to home.
She is calling for a written constitution to enshrine rights for women and children.
Campaigners have made their case for and against Scottish independence in a 'Town Hall' style debate.
Things were a lot more civlised in tonight's 'town hall' style debate than in the head-to-heads between Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling.
Some of the leading players in the Yes and No campaigns battle it out in the third major debate on Scottish independence.