Labour's Mick Antoniw tells Political Editor Adrian Masters that the Welsh Government's decision on the M4 relief road project 'could have been handled better.'
He's a member of the Environment Committee which completed its report into the plan today. Other Labour members are also said to be disappointed that the announcement was made before the committee finished its scrutiny.
Plaid Cymru's Shadow Transport Spokesman, Rhun ap Iorwerth says he believes that todays decision is a costly mistake. He believes that there will be a 15 year wait for the project to be delivered when an alternative route could have been completed a decade sooner.
Environmental campaigners Friends of the Earth and sustainable transport charity Sustrans have both condemned the decision to go ahead with a new motorway. They claim it will devastate nationally important wildlife sites in the Gwent Levels south of Newport. They also predict that the motorway won't open to traffic for more than a decade and that the billion pound cost will starve more worthwhile transport projects of funds.
This vastly expensive, utterly unnecessary and terribly damaging motorway is the worst possible transport choice for south east Wales. And the billion pound price tag means that, at a time when traffic has actually decreased since 2007, it’s going to come at the cost of the sustainable solutions that could benefit us all. Investment in public transport and some modest road improvements could improve transport in the area at a fraction of the cost, and we could be seeing the benefits almost immediately.
– Gareth Clubb, Friends of the Earth Cymru
£1 billion for a new section of motorway is the wrong transport priority for Wales. Investment in public transport must be the priority for building a sustainable and efficient economy, yet the Welsh Government’s consultation on the need for an M4 relief road scheme didn’t take into account other proposals that will reduce demand, such as the Metro programme, or evidence showing that car use is now in decline.
The Conservatives have broadly welcomed the go-ahead for the M4 relief motorway but claimed that today's announcement by Economy and Transport Minister Edwina Hart could trigger legal challenges.
A long time coming, today’s announcement at least shows progress and willing – finally. Make no mistake – the spades must start digging and businesses and travellers given the relief so sorely needed. Under no circumstances must that come at the expense of scrutiny – and today’s last-minute announcement has failed to take environmental concerns into account, or provide relevant detail. Welsh Conservatives have long called for M4 relief – and, while this must happen swiftly, it must happen appropriately.
– shadow Transport Minister Byron Davies AM
This announcement today fails to take into account substantial concerns about the elimination of the Blue Route. There is a serious and substantial failure to comply with the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive and the Minister’s announcement today is likely to be mired in legal challenges for years to come. The potential environmental damage caused by the Ministers failure to consider properly the Blue Route is short termism at its worst.
– Shadow Environment Minister Antoinette Sandback AM
The Welsh Liberal Democrats say today's go ahead for a new motorway around Newport by 2021 is a "huge mistake" by Economy and Transport Minister Edwina Hart. They say it ignores environmental concerns raised during the consultation on alternative proposals.
The consultation process appears to have been nothing more than a sham. The Minister’s claim that there were no reasons why the ‘black route’ could not be adopted completely ignores evidence provided to her by the RSPB, Sustrans and the Federation of Small Businesses.
There are still huge questions surrounding the economic benefit of this development. Investing the Welsh Government’s entire borrowing powers into one single road leaves no money left for other transport projects like the South Wales Metro, which can provide much greater economic benefit for the whole area.
Our proposed alternatives are far less expensive, less likely to damage vast swathes of our environment and are academically recommended. It’s shocking that the Welsh Labour Minister is remaining blinkered, ignoring these credible proposals and ploughing ahead regardless.
– Liberal Democrat Economy spokesperson Eluned Parrott AM
Three Labour backbench AMs have attacked the announcement of an M4 relief motorway,. They were unhappy with either the decision itself or the timing of Edwina Hart's statement.
Pontypridd AM Mick Antoniw and Cardiff North's Julie Morgan are both members of the Assembly Environment Committee. They were unhappy that the minister had not waited for their committee's report on the proposal and had not even agreed to appear before them.
The minister replied that she could not not appear before the committee until she had taken her decision for fear of a legal challenge on the grounds that she had not acted impartially. Mr Antoniw, who's a lawyer warned that the minister had in fact left herself open to a legal challenge by her actions.
Cardiff Central Labour AM Jenny Rathbone argued that new roads inevitably generate more traffic and said her constituents would be disappointed by the decision.
Plaid Cymru have condemned as outrage the decision by the Economy and Transport Minister, Edwina Hart, to reject alternatives to a new motorway south of Newport and announce a timetable for building the M4 relief road.
Plaid Cymru believes that today’s decision is a costly mistake. It is costly for the economy in that there will be a 15 year wait for this project to be delivered when an alternative route could have been completed a decade sooner. But it is also hugely costly for the Welsh public purse – why go for a £1 billion pound route that will mean infrastructure projects losing out right across Wales, when the £400 million blue route would have solved the problem and left hundreds of millions of pounds extra for investment elsewhere.
– Plaid Cymru Transport Spokesperson Rhun ap Iorwerth AM