The family of a woman murdered in Cardiff in 1996, say today's decision by the Appeal Court to reject the appeal by the man convicted for killing her has ended a 16 year nightmare.
The judge dismissed John Pope's appeal against his conviction for murdering housewife Karen Skipper.
Karen's three sisters later spoke of their relief that her killer had finally been brought to justice.
Our lives have been on hold for the past 16 years ever since Karen was killed. It has been an emotional roller coaster but we can now get on with our lives although we will never forget our loving sister. We have been told there will be no more appeals and now Karen can rest in peace.
The jury in the trial of a man convicted of killing four people in Pembrokeshire in the 1980s, were "profoundly misdirected", according to his legal team.
John Cooper, was convicted last year of shooting dead Peter and Gwenda Dixon on a coastal path in Little Haven, Pembrokeshire. He was also found guilty of murdering sister and brother Helen and Richard Thomas in their home near Milford Haven.
In today's hearing to decide if Cooper can appeal his life sentence his legal team claimed there was 'clear room for confusion in the jury's mind' during the trial.
The judgement has been reserved for two weeks.
Joanna Simpson was at the Court of Appeal in Cardiff.