John Osmond, Director of the Institute of Welsh Affairs, told us "Cardiff Airport is in the wrong place in relation to the population of the region."
The think tank has acknowledged that Bristol Airport is more successful, but argues that neither existing airport is in an ideal location, or has good enough regional transport links.
More top news
Wales are very, very close to qualifying for France but after decades of disappointment, here's how they can make it mathematically certain.
Drivers using hand car washes are being offered sex with trafficked women according to an anti-slavery worker
Reece Charles Wynne produced a beer bottle, put it to his victim's neck and demanded money.