The Ombudsman found that "surgery was too risky for symptom control only, unless [the patient] had wished to proceed on a fully informed basis."
Upholding the family's complaint he said he "found that the surgeon was acting at the limit of his skills in undertaking such complex surgery."
More top news
Winds will strengthen to gale force by dawn, these severe across exposed coasts and hills particularly in the southwest.
A Swansea charity worker says he was left "shocked and saddened" after being questioned by counter-terrorism officers returning from Iraq.
Our Valleys Correspondent Hannah Thomas has been exploring the beauty of Blaenau Gwent.