Dedicated foodie Sarah Merker munches 244 scones to reveal Britain's best at National Trust sites

Scone woman
One of the 244 scones eaten by Sarah Merker Credit: Sarah Merker

A dedicated foodie with a serious love of scones who has finished a decade-long project to eat a scone at every possible National Trust location - a total of 244 - and unveil the secret to Britain’s perfect scone. Sarah Merker, 49, from Isleworth, London, documented her mammouth journey eating the sweet treat at every National Trust location in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland that can provide one. Her mission ended when Ms Merker visited the Giant’s Causeway in Northern Ireland for one last scone, to feel as though she had finished the task alongside her husband, Peter, who died from cancer in 2018.

“It’s all very emotional, it’s been a weird experience,” Ms Merker, a marketing director, said. “I don’t know what I’d call it – it’s more than a hobby… It’s taken up a lot of my time and effort over the past 10 years and I’ll really miss it. “It’s just played a very important part of my life.”

Sarah Merker's husband, Peter, who died in 2018 from cancer Credit: Sarah Merker

Ms Merker was inspired to start sampling scones in 2013 after buying an £84 annual membership for Europe’s largest conservation charity.

There is a separate National Trust for Scotland, but with access to more than 500 properties in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland, Ms Merker began a ranking and review process for each location scones were on the menu – as well as a Twitter account to record her findings, which has accrued a following of over 7,000.

“I thought it would take me maybe five years or something, I didn’t expect to do it quickly,” she said. “But I didn’t think it would take me 10 years. “It’s been educational, it’s been my holidays, it’s been weekends.” Part of the experience Ms Merker shared with her husband, Peter, who was diagnosed with cancer in 2016 and died two years later. Marking the end of the project at the Giant’s Causeway, Ms Merker said it was her way of finishing it with him.

Sarah Merker finished her scone eating marathon this week Credit: Sarah Merker

“He’d been there for so much of it and obviously I have memories of doing it with him,” she said. “So, for me, it was really important to finish it for him as well – I wanted to make sure I got to the end. “And that’s one of the reasons why I kept (the) Giant’s Causeway till the end, because me and him came here before we joined the National Trust, so I knew that he had seen it before.”

Ms Merker’s blog called was even turned into a book – The National Trust Book of Scones. Her dedication to the project never wavered, though the frequency of scone-sampling did fluctuate, such as when it was harder to get to locations during the pandemic or a particularly busy August in 2019 where she managed 26. After 244 scones, Ms Merker revealed the secret to making them perfect every time.

“There is a secret to scones and it’s the easiest secret ever,” she said. “The secret to a scone is that it has to be fresh. “It takes a lot to ruin a fresh score… As long as the scone has been baked that day, you can hardly ever go wrong.” And while she could not name a bad scone – though admitted there have been two – she did speak about the one that stands out as a favourite from a decade of tasting: a Christmas pudding scone with brandy butter at Treasurer’s House, Yorkshire.

“There’s about 90 odd, or I think there’s nearly 100 scones that have been given the five stars.” Ms Merker also added that “the best thing about the Twitter following” is the people she has met. “I’ve just met some of the loveliest people, like people I would genuinely be friends with in real life,” she said. “There’s a real little community on Twitter that we’ve managed to build. “The thing about the National Trust is that there is something for everyone and I mean that.”

Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know...