Conservatives plan English MPs 'veto' on English laws

MPs representing Scottish constituencies would be stripped of the power to "impose" income tax rate changes on the rest of the UK under a parliamentary shake-up planned by the Conservatives.

Live updates

Tories unveil plans for 'English votes for English laws'

The Conservative Party laid out its proposals for "English votes for English laws" today.

House of Commons leader William Hague said the planned devolution of more powers to the Scottish government creates "imbalances" that do not favour English MPs.

ITV News' Political Editor Tom Bradby reports:

Scottish MPs 'could block English laws' under new plans

William Hague has unveiled plans that would see English MPs set their own country's income tax rates.

The Commons Leader said the reforms are a "fundamental matter of fairness".

ITV News Political Correspondent Carl Dinnen explains the plans:

Advertisement

Hague 'English votes' plans face backbench battle

William Hague tried to draw Labour further into the English votes debate as he accused them of "betraying" voters as he set out the Conservative blueprint for delivering "English votes for English laws."

However the proposals still face a tough battle with some in the Conservative party who believe the plans are too weak and would make the situation worse by providing nationalist MPs with a "battering ram against the Union".

Leader of the House of Commons, William Hague. Credit: Philip Toscano/PA Wire

Under the Tory manifesto proposals - which Mr Hague is seeking to put to a Commons vote before May's general election - policies affecting England alone would be scrutinised by a panel made up only of MPs representing English seats.

A "grand committee" of all English MPs would then have to approve the legislation. Welsh MPs would be included on matters not devolved to the Cardiff Assembly.

A large section of Tory backbenchers are angry that the final - Third Reading - vote on Bills would still include MPs from the rest of the UK, in what they say is a watering down of David Cameron's promise to act.

Ukip slam English votes 'back room stitch-up' plans

The deupty leader of Ukip has slammed Conservative palns for English MPs to be given vetoes.

Paul Nuttall says the proposals panders to the culture of "back room stitch-ups."

UKIP MEP for North West England, UKIP Deputy Leader Paul Nuttall Credit: EMPICS Entertainment/EMPICS Entertainment

We cannot have the tail wagging the dog.

It would create chaos where one group of MPs were being pitted against another. It would be cleaner and fairer for English only issues to be voted on by MPs in English constituencies.

It is likely that after the General Election there will be more SNP members of parliament sitting in Westminster whose concern will be Scotland and not what is best for England. In that situation these plans would add layers of process and confusion to legislating and lead to back room deals being made far away from the voters eyes.

Why are the Tories are climbing down for English only votes? Is there already a back room stitch-up?

– Paul Nuttall, North West MEP

Conservatives plans for English MPs 'veto' on English laws

MPs representing Scottish constituencies would be stripped of the power to "impose" income tax rate changes on the rest of the UK under a parliamentary shake-up planned by the Conservatives.

It would give an effective veto to MPs for seats in England - and Wales on some policies - over matters that are decided north of the border by the Scottish Parliament, but would still require a majority of all UK MPs to pass legislation.

House of Commons Credit: CROFT MALCOLM CROFT/PA Archive/Press Association Images

Under the preferred option, only English MPs would consider the amending stages of legislation that relates only to England and have a veto via a procedure known as a legislative consent motion.

English votes for English laws 'would be fair all round'

William Hague has described how English votes for English laws would work in the UK Parliament.

The former Foreign Secretary told Good Morning Britain that: "If we're proposing to change the level of health spending in England then that does have an affect on Scotland and that is for all MPs to vote on. But if we're voting on how to share out the health spending in England in the different parts of England that should require the agreement of the English MPs."

Advertisement

Back to top