The director of civil rights lobby group Liberty said she was "delighted" that Labour pledged to scrap Police and Crime Commissioners, saying they were always a "very dangerous development".
This was always a very dangerous development from a rule of law point of view, because you directly elect a charismatic individual politician to boss the chief constable around, to hire and fire the chief constable and to meddle in operational policing.
We have seen power being used to influence chief constables, their contracts not being renewed for a long time, we've seen scandals and corruption and I think partly that's why this experiment has now failed.
It wasn't just a failed experiment, it was wrong in principle - democracy cannot exist without the rule of law, and that means independent judges and chief constables.
More top news
Stephen-Alan Nicholson, of no fixed abode, will appear at Southampton Magistrates’ Court charged with murder.
The First Minister had already said the deal was bad for Scotland.
The winning ticket in the November 2 draw was purchased in the Boston and Skegness parliamentary constituency area.