Police source leaking sensitive material on Noah Donohoe case online, family's lawyer claims

Noah Donohoe was found dead in a storm drain June 2020. Credit: Family photo

A lawyer for the family of Noah Donohoe has claimed a police source is leaking sensitive material on social media relating to the schoolboy's death.

The claim emerged during a hearing to determine whether the police should be allowed to withhold some material during the upcoming inquest.

The Secretary of State had signed a Public Interest Immunity certificate in July.

High Court Judge Mister Justice Humphries said that he would make a decision on the PII within the next week.

After the PII was signed, the the Northern Ireland Office moved to distance itself and the Secretary of State from the issuing of a certificate. It said the application was made by the PSNI and the ultimate decision was down to the coroner.

Justice Humphreys said there is nothing "sinister" about the fact PII hearings are held in private. He said PIIs were common in Northern Ireland.

He said it is necessary to consider the material at the heart of the application.

"I also want to stress that the decision ultimately is being made by an independent judicial officer," he added.

"As a High Court judge, I hold no brief for anyone. I'm not here to toe anyone's line. I'm not here to wave a ministerial flag...

"The decision here will be made with absolute independence and integrity."

Mr Justice Michael Humphreys said he is aware of the level of controversy generated by the Government-backed Public Interest Immunity (PII) application by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI).

The PSNI argues that disclosing the information, which includes details on police methodologies and source handling, would damage national security interests.

Donal Lunny QC, representing the PSNI, told the court the redactions are not excessive and mainly relate to reference numbers, the grading of intelligence, information on sources and details on police methodology.

He insisted there is a "real risk" to the national interest if the material is disclosed in open court.

Annexes attached to the PII document signed off by Mr Vara reference dissident republican attacks in recent years.

Mr Lunny told the court that information was relevant as the disclosure of police methodologies could directly benefit terrorist groups in Northern Ireland.

"The predominant basis upon which PII is sought in this case is national security to do with law enforcement methodology and capability," he said.

"If certain information about methodology or capability were in the public domain, one of the groups to whom that information is likely to be of use are terrorist groups."

The barrister said the application was not like others that had come before the courts that involved page after page of material being blacked out.

"On the ultimate question of, 'Is it possible to have a fair inquest in the interest of justice with these redactions applied?' I would submit, 'Absolutely, yes'," he said.

Brenda Campbell QC, representing the Donohoe family, accepted that PII applications are not uncommon in the coroner's court, particularly for Troubles-related killings, but she questioned why issues of national security are at play in a case involving a child's death.

"We must bear in mind that at the heart of this inquest is the death of a 14-year-old child," she said.

"A bright and talented and popular boy who had a zest for life. Who was loved and was loving and impressed everyone who knew him and that child left home on a bright Sunday afternoon in June 2020 and whose naked body was found six days later face down in a storm drain."

She added: "At the heart of this inquest is a grieving mother and a grieving family who need to understand how and why Noah died.

"However painful answers that are forthcoming might be, they are not as painful as the unknown as to how and why he died."

Ms Donohoe and her sister Niamh watched proceedings from the back of court during Thursday's open hearing.

The barrister noted the significant rumour and suspicion the case has generated.

She said some of it was "ill founded, harmful and unwelcome".

"I think it's important that I should make clear on behalf of Noah's mother that she has no interest in igniting rumour and suspicion, and that much of that has been deeply painful and very unhelpful to her," she added.

It was explained to the court that labels were being applied to redactions in order to explain the need to withhold the material.

Ms Campbell said the proposed redaction of intelligence grading assessments would hamper the family in scrutinising whether the police responded appropriately to intelligence suggesting third party involvement in Noah's death.

The barrister said the inquest's purpose is not only to determine how Noah died but also to examine his family's concerns about the police's handling of the case.

"Withholding material that can safely be disclosed will undoubtedly do more harm than good and undermine further the public confidence in the administration of justice," she said.

"If this inquest can properly and fully address these issues, it will serve to quell rumour and suspicion.

"Withholding or concealing information in relation to those really is the antithesis of what we hope to achieve."

During legal exchanges on Thursday, Ms Campbell also aired concerns that sensitive information about the case was being leaked on social media from a "police source".

Mr Lunny said the PSNI was not aware of any unauthorised disclosure related to the investigation.

After the PII hearing, the court reconvened again briefly in open session.

Justice Humphreys thanked the legal representatives involved for their "very well prepared and careful submissions".

He said while the PII process involves "complex and niche" areas of law, the "human tragedy" at the centre of the case should not be forgotten.

The controversy around the PII was raised at a rally in Belfast in August with the Sinn Fein MP for North Belfast John Finucane saying that Noah’s mother’s “fight for the answers she deserves” is supported by many, and MLA Gerry Carroll claiming that the case had been “mishandled”.

The law firm representing the family of schoolboy Noah Donohoe also expressed "grave concerns" over the actions of the Secretary of State.

Noah, 14, a pupil at St Malachy's College in Belfast, was found dead in a storm drain in the north of the city in June 2020, six days after going missing.

He disappeared while cycling from his home in south Belfast to meet friends across the city.< Police have ruled out foul play.

Noah's mother, Fiona Donohoe, is hoping for answers to some of the questions surrounding her son's mysterious disappearance and death through the inquest process.

She has been campaigning for the police files to be released in full and has gained significant public backing.

A petition opposing the PII bid has gained more than 300,000 signatures, while supporters of the Donohoe family staged a protest in Belfast city centre last month.

The coroner said he will deliver his findings by next Friday.

Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know.