Hain's legal battle over book

Shadow Welsh Secretary and his publisher accused of contempt of court

Live updates


Hain case 'fundamentally important' - Davis

The EDM tabled by David Davis MP in support of Peter Hain has attracted 123 signatures in 24 hours. Mr Davis says

This is an extraordinarily important issue. In the event that this legal action against Mr Hain succeeded members of parliament and even Ministers would feel extraordinarily constrained in any criticism they might make of the judicial process and judiciary in the United Kingdom. Even the threat of the costs and distraction involved in dealing with such an action would have a severe chilling effect on the freedom of speech which is fundamental in keeping our institutions healthy.

The importance of this issue is reinforced by the number of MPs who have immediately signed it, and by the number of ex Cabinet Ministers including previous Home Secretaries who have given their support.


Peter Hain statement

I am astonished at this turn of events. I worked harder than anyone as Secretary of State for Northern Ireland to uphold the rule of law and judicial independence and delivered the 2007 settlement which helped secure that. If free speech and comment in a political memoir is to be suppressed then people will be entitled to ask: what system of justice prevails?"

Hain publisher statement

Iain Dale, managing director of Biteback publishing says:

I am advised that proceedings for contempt for criticising judges have been considered obsolete in England and Wales since the end of the nineteenth century. Our lawyers are not aware of any such case having been brought in Northern Ireland in living memory. As a publisher I strongly support free speech, not least by our elected politicians, and we will therefore be vigorously defending this case.

As is normal in the case of memoirs of former cabinet ministers, we submitted the manuscript of the book to the Cabinet Office and the Northern Ireland Office for their comments in advance of publication. Neither office requested any changes to those parts of the book that relate to Judge Girvan

Back to top

Latest ITV News reports